Monday, February 9, 2009

Running and Core Stability

I’m still in the UK having spent the weekend at the TCR (Triathlon, Cycling and Running) Expo in London. I had a great time meeting people, attending some talks and doing a few of my own. On Sunday I sat in on a talk by a local physical therapist (called a ‘physio’ here). He had some great action videos shot of various runners of many different abilities. Each was running barefoot on a treadmill with a view from the back. I wish I had gotten his name and business affiliation but I failed to do so as I got there after the introduction.

The first video he showed was of a sub-2:20 marathoner who had been running for several years. This runner certainly had what could be called ‘excessive pronation.’ Shortly after footstrike, which appeared to be fairly midfoot, his foot collapsed medially (to the inside) quite a bit. Yet when the video was freeze framed at this point and advanced one frame at a time there was no medial collapse of the knee. In fact, the knee and leg held a straight line from the hip to the ankle. That is unusual for a runner with such an extreme amount of pronation. Maintaining a straight line from hip to ankle means that the core muscles must be quite strong to keep the hip from dropping as the recovery leg swings through. If the hip drops the knee must collapse to maintain balance. With this runner, again being viewed from the back, the waistline of his shorts remained perfectly horizontal. That was because his core muscles kept everything nicely in place. So despite an excessively pronated foot there was no medial or lateral stress being placed on the leg, knee or hip. And, in fact, this athlete reported that he had never been injured despite many years of running.

Another video was presented in which a young female runner was viewed from the back as she ran. Her foot and ankle movement were nearly textbook with the ankle showing only a slight amount of pronation, which is considered ‘normal.’ However, she reported a significant history of iliotibial band (ITB) injuries. It was obvious why this was the case. As her recovery leg would swing through the hip on that side collapsed and the knee of the support leg buckled in considerably as a result. Going farther up the chain it was evident that her core muscles were quite weak because the waistband on her shorts rocked up and down pivoting around her SI joint region.

The bottom line of his presentation was that the core muscles are at least as critical to running stability and performance as are the feet. He gave an excellent presentation and much food for thought. I only wish I had gotten his name.

Labels: ,

24 Comments:

At February 9, 2009 9:31 AM , Anonymous Ed said...

Phone the organisers. Now I'm all curious and I want to know more, but you've got the information (time and room number of presentation)!

 
At February 9, 2009 11:09 AM , Blogger jaime vigaray said...

Maybe these guys :
http://www.physio4life.co.uk/

 
At February 9, 2009 1:08 PM , Anonymous Jason D said...

Hi Joe,

I wonder if this is your guy:

http://www.tcrshow.com/SeminarsWorkshops/GatoradeImproveyourPerformanceTheatre/tabid/455/Default.aspx

Physio4life

http://www.physio4life.co.uk/

 
At February 9, 2009 1:25 PM , Blogger Bryan said...

Hi Joe,
As someone with a long history of IT band injury this post has given me a lot to ponder. I’d better start working on those long neglected core muscles.
Thanks,
Bryan

 
At February 10, 2009 11:30 AM , Anonymous Janet said...

Hi Joe

The seminar was given by someone from Physio4life (an excellent and innovative clinic based in Putney, SW London).

The clinic director is Mark Saunders, (Chrissie Wellington's physiotherapist).

 
At February 10, 2009 11:34 AM , Anonymous Janet said...

Hi Joe

This session was given by someone from Physio4life (an excellent and innovative clinic based in Putney, SW London).

The clinic director in Mark Saunders (Chrissie Wellington's physiotherapist).

 
At February 10, 2009 1:53 PM , Blogger Coach Al said...

HI Joe,

Hope all is well. Everything you've said is the reason why I created Runner-CORE. To read more about this topic, I'd highly recommend you reach Bosch and Klomp's book, "Running-Biomechanics and Physiology in Practice." A GREAT book.

What most don't realize is how much the pelvis area is directly responsible for what happens at the feet. I routinely see runners with calf/achilles tendonitis, and the cause for this isn't weak or tight calves, its immobile and/or tight hips. That is, in the same way that core strength ("stiffness") is critical for injury prevention and performance, the hips/pelvis also needs to be able to rotate freely through recovery and into stance and pushoff. If it can't because of tightness, then the impact forces get transferred down the chain to another area that must compensate. My running clinics now, are focused entirely around the concepts of balanced strength and mobility, for run injury resistance AND performance, at least as a starting point...

Thanks for the post,

Take care,
Al Lyman

 
At February 10, 2009 3:28 PM , Blogger Janine Jacoby said...

When someone says core muscles, I think most people immediately think abs. Can you expand on what specifically you believe core muscles to include?

Thanks,

Janine

 
At February 11, 2009 11:29 AM , Blogger Joe said...

Great post and gives me insight into my rectent ITB problems!!

More situps and back exercises tonight!!!!

 
At February 12, 2009 4:47 AM , Blogger Franz Huber said...

Very interesting.
Since you have a lot of experience, it would be great to know more about your insights into ITBS problems, particularly of cyclists.
Maybe some more blog entries on this?

 
At February 16, 2009 10:06 AM , Anonymous Shane84 said...

You authored different Running weight workouts in trainingpeaks.com for trainingpeaks account subscribers to follow for runners under workout descriptions. I know they are subdivided into different phases AA, ME, MS, etc for periodization. Are these workouts sufficient enough for maintaining core stabiblty for runners?

 
At February 16, 2009 12:16 PM , Blogger Joe Friel said...

Shane 84--For a few it is, I'm sure. But for most it is not enough, I'm afraid.

 
At February 17, 2009 1:44 PM , Anonymous Anonymous said...

Joe,

Thank you for posting the article especially about the sub 2:20 marathoner with his levelled pelvis and no suffering from medial and lateral stress issues, which in fact what I am founding as well as I am a Chi-runner. Btw, part of the Chi-running posture alignment calls for a levelled pelvis for fore/aft and side to side stability and I am using these focuses to control pronation problem I have on my left foot. May I have your permission to use your article in my biomechanic speech I'm giving next week in particular to this individual's example, because this was the exact conern our Canadian physios have! In my part of town/ Canada, most of the medical community are still anti-midfoot striking. They are pro heel striking. A physio and podiatrist gave talks saying that midfoot strike will and can cause a lot more serious injuries than heel striking because of the medial and lateral stresses they can impose.
Obviously, your article shed some light that with good core stability, this will not become a concern as with myself. No running injuries running marathons -- though not a sub 2:20 that's for sure!

Thanks,

David.

 
At February 17, 2009 5:37 PM , Blogger Joe Friel said...

David--Thanks for your note. Yes, please feel free to use that blog. Good luck.

 
At February 17, 2009 8:09 PM , Blogger AshevilleMountainBikeRacing said...

Joe,

I'm having a very hard finding support for non specific training of elite level endurance atheletes.

Does the "sub 2:20" marathoner do anything except run in order to have such great form? In reality, could anything but running have such an effect?

The leap isn't made in this post to suggest "core training"; however on the heels of the webinar on this topic I can't help but assume where you stand.

-Marshall Hance
Asheville, NC

 
At February 19, 2009 12:22 AM , Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hi Joe,

I'm glad you enjoyed the talk and I thought I would clarify that the talk was taken by Mark Saunders and he is the Director of Physio4Life in Putney SW London.
If anyone would like any further information on the talk then please do not hesitate to contact me on amy@physio4life.co.uk and I will be happy to help.

Regards
Amy

 
At February 20, 2009 5:23 AM , Blogger Steph said...

I'm being treated by a 'physio' at this guy's (Mark Saunders) clinic in London at the moment. Highly recommended, Mark and his staff at Physio4Life really know their stuff. I only wish I wasn't injured... ha ha.

I'm sure he can hook you up with a powerpoint or whatever of that presentation if you drop him a line via the physio4life website.

 
At February 23, 2009 11:25 AM , Blogger cmeek said...

Having had a session with Mark today, I have seen some nasty video footage of me running. I definitely fall into the second type of runner with my pelvis dipping and diving all over the place. This has given me lots to think about - just think how much I can improve my times when I get this sorted!! Thank you Mark.

 
At March 8, 2009 10:06 AM , Anonymous Ed said...

Fascinating post! It helps me to better understand what I learned from a therapist in the US named Bob Gajda who does a lot of work on rehab and performance that involves core. Someone said "time to do more situps," but if I'm guessing correctly, then in fact you want less of that and more of exercises that challenge integration across the pelvis. For example, if you stand on a block with one foot and attach a cable or resistance band to the opposite ankle, you can execute a cycling motion (hip flex, knee extension, etc.). Focus on your posture and you will be forced to stabilize the motion through the pelvis, activating the glutes on the standing leg and using muscles above the pelvis to stabilize it as you bear the side-to-side torque. Or, you can flip around and make a donkey kick (you'll feel your hamstrings challenged), and again the core will have to stabilize the motion by stabilizing the pelvis. Even balancing on one foot while standing on something unstable, like a sponge, can help if you focus on posture and activating the glutes of the standing leg. (or, do hip hikes when standing on the sponge). Someone mentioned training with the physio that gave the presentation. Does this sound like the kind of thing you were doing? They are dynamic core exercises rather than static strength. -Ed

 
At March 8, 2009 10:08 AM , Anonymous Ed said...

Fascinating post! It helps me to better understand what I learned from a therapist in the US named Bob Gajda who does a lot of work on rehab and performance that involves core. Someone said "time to do more situps," but if I'm guessing correctly, then in fact you want less of that and more of exercises that challenge integration across the pelvis. For example, if you stand on a block with one foot and attach a cable or resistance band to the opposite ankle, you can execute a cycling motion (hip flex, knee extension, etc.). Focus on your posture and you will be forced to stabilize the motion through the pelvis, activating the glutes on the standing leg and using muscles above the pelvis to stabilize it as you bear the side-to-side torque. Or, you can flip around and make a donkey kick (you'll feel your hamstrings challenged), and again the core will have to stabilize the motion by stabilizing the pelvis. Even balancing on one foot while standing on something unstable, like a sponge, can help if you focus on posture and activating the glutes of the standing leg. (or, do hip hikes when standing on the sponge). Someone mentioned training with the physio that gave the presentation. Does this sound like the kind of thing you were doing? They are dynamic core exercises rather than static strength. -Ed

 
At March 8, 2009 7:12 PM , Blogger Joe Friel said...

Yes, Ed, and more. You certainly have the right idea.

 
At March 8, 2009 7:50 PM , Anonymous Ed said...

Oops. Maybe I should have signed, "Ed2" to avoid confusing things with the other Ed who posted! Too many Eds. -Ed

 
At October 13, 2009 9:22 AM , Blogger Ian said...

The following comments are by no means to undermine the core strength that does help all athletic performance. I am a physical therapist in scottsdale arizona and have specialized with runners, biomechanics, orthotics by taking a functional approach. One major factor that I feel is missing in the analysis of the elite level runner vs the average jogger is the running efficiency of the two runners. From the video analysis I have perform ed over the last 8 years I have noticed that an elite running will be so efficient compared to the average jogger that their foot will spend almost half the time on the ground(efficiency!). This efficiency will result in less time for the rest of the lower leg/hip/pelvis to lose efficiency. I have also noticed that many elite endurance runners are not extremely strong in their core. Distance running is not about power/strength but rather about efficiency over the distance.

 
At January 3, 2010 5:18 PM , Anonymous Tom said...

Wow just look at how much Haille Gebrselassie overpronates in this you tube vid. The video commentry is very informative aswell, worth a look

http://www.youtube.com/njsportsmed#p/u/3/EAW87NsiGuI

 

Post a Comment

<< Home